Five years later

While the rest of us have been busy getting on with our lives, most likely taking our freedom and ability to travel from A to B completely for granted, Dr Ágnes Geréb is still in detention, of sorts. Can it really be five years since I first wrote about her? Yes. I checked the dates. My piece published in the Budapest Times on 25 October 2010. And that’s as good as five years ago.

Arrested and imprisoned without trial five years ago for practising midwifery, Dr Geréb was later released to house arrest in December 2010 where she remained until February last year. Imagine not being able to leave the confines of your house for years. I go stir-crazy if I can’t leave for three days! In 2014, the conditions of her house arrest were relaxed a little so while she can travel in and around Budapest, she can’t venture much further afield. A prison as beautiful as Budapest is still a prison if you can’t leave.

As with all things newsworthy, the story soon faded. A band of committed supporters (both local and international) have kept the candle lighting and now they’re raising funds to pay legal and medical expert fees relating to Dr Geréb’s court cases. All contributions are welcomed at The sum ‒ less than €12 000 ‒ is paltry when compared to the hundreds of thousands if not millions spent on court cases worldwide. But for someone who has effectively been barred from earning a living as a doctor, as a midwife, or as a psychologist (she is qualified to practise each), it may as well be millions rather than thousands.

For those of you who need a reminder: Dr Geréb had a patient whom she had advised not to choose home birth because of a pre-existing health condition. During a scheduled prenatal appointment, the patient suddenly went into labour and the baby was delivered – apparently there was no time to get her to the hospital. When born, the baby had breathing difficulties. Ambulance staff called to the scene began resuscitation and took the baby to hospital. Dr Geréb was subsequently questioned, arrested, and taken into custody.  Today, she is fighting a series of additional charges issued after her arrest around birth incidents which pre-date that fateful October night, all of them wrongly placed in a criminal court and all of them still unresolved as she staunchly defends her innocence and her reputation.

Dr Geréb is an internationally acknowledged midwife and a defender of the rights of mothers to control the circumstances of their baby’s birth. Surely the right of a woman to choose how and where she delivers her child is a basic one. For those who argue that home birth puts the life of the child at more risk than a hospital birth, one only has to look to statistics to see how tenuous that argument is. For those who still argue that the state is not responsible for facilitating the choice of home delivery, then they should remember the Ternovsky ruling of 2010 which obliged the Hungarian government to do exactly that.

I am not a mother. I have never given birth. I can’t say whether I’d prefer to be in a hospital or at home should the occasion arise. I simply do not know. But I do know that I’d like the choice. And it’s women like Dr Geréb, professionals who stand tall in the eyes of the thousands of parents in Hungary whose children were born at her hands, who make that choice possible.  Let’s remember what she stands for. Let’s remember what she’s going through. Let’s remember to donate.

First published in the Budapest Times 23 October 2015

Subscribe to get notified when I publish something new.

3 Responses

  1. In the UK, women without health concerns are advised by NICE to birth at home or at a midwife led unit (no doctors). This follows the Birthplace Study (2011) which found that for “low risk” mothers, they were safer out of hospital in all cases. While there may be a tiny increased risk that the baby would experience an adverse event such as meconium aspiration, this only applies to first babies, and only to a specific type of injury, and only in very, tiny, barely statistically significant numbers. For subsequent births there were no additional serious risks to the baby, and lower risks of less serious problems at a planned home birth V planned hospital birth.

    1. Given the state of hospitals in Ireland and in Hungary, I’d say we’re all safer out of hospitals. Yet it’s interesting how conditioned we are to believing otherwise.

Talk to me...

%d bloggers like this:

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information on cookies and GDPR

Cookies and GDPR Compliance

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

General Data Protection Regulation

If you have voluntarily submitted your email address so that you can receive notifications of new posts, please be assured that I don't use your address for anything other than to do just that - and that's done automatically. I might use your address, if I knew how to, but I don't.

This blog does not make money, it does not carry sponsored content, it has no ads for which I receive any form of payment. If I review a place or a restaurant or a book, I don't receive any compensation from anyone. I wish I did, but that would require marketing myself and life is too short. If something changes, I will be sure to let you know.

You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the unsubscribe or manage subscription links at the bottom of every email you receive. When you comment on a blog post, Google Analytics tracks where you're posting from. This is stored and I can check my stats to see how many clicks I had today, where people clicked from, and what they clicked on. That's it. Nothing more.

I reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive, particularly to other commenters. If you want to have one of your comments deleted, the please get in touch with me at: I'm all for the right to be forgotten so will happily oblige.

So, in a nutshell, if you give me your email address voluntarily to subscribe to new posts or if you opt to subscribe to new comments, then you email is just used for this. Nothing else. Promise.